If you think nonprofit email marketing is outdated or ineffective, think again.
Email is still one of the highest-ROI channels for small nonprofits. It reaches your audience directly, allows for personalized storytelling, and costs next to nothing compared to paid advertising. But without a clear strategy, it’s easy to fall into the trap of inconsistency, low engagement, or, worse, unsubscribes.
Let’s break down the do’s and don’ts of email marketing for small nonprofits so you can build trust, increase engagement, and keep your community coming back for more.
✅ DO: Send Emails on a Consistent Schedule
A newsletter isn’t just a tool—it’s a relationship. And relationships require consistency.
Whether you commit to once a month or twice a quarter, make it sustainable. Sporadic sending confuses subscribers and kills momentum. Let your audience know when to expect your newsletter—and stick to it.
❌ DON’T: Email Only When You Need Something
Don’t let your newsletter become a panic button you only hit when it’s time to fundraise.
Nonprofit email marketing is most effective when it’s a two-way street. Share stories, wins, behind-the-scenes moments, or even lessons learned. If every subject line is “Urgent—Donate Now,” readers will tune out.
✅ DO: Lead with Value
The best newsletters answer this question: “What’s in it for the reader?”
- Is it a quick tip for getting involved locally?
- A heartfelt impact story with photos?
- A behind-the-scenes look at how donations are used?
Lead with value first, and the ask will feel earned.
❌ DON’T: Write Novels
Emails should be snackable, not overwhelming. A good rule of thumb: if it’s longer than your phone screen, it better be riveting.
Stick to one topic per email. Link out to your blog or website for longer reads.
✅ DO: Use a Clear, Compelling Subject Line
Your subject line is your email’s first—and sometimes only—chance to stand out. Make it count.
Try:
- “See the impact YOU made this month”
- “What 5 volunteers taught us about resilience”
- “Our biggest challenge yet (and how we’re facing it)”
Avoid vague, filler phrases like “Monthly Update” or “Organization Newsletter.”
❌ DON’T: Ignore Mobile Users
Over 40% of nonprofit emails are opened on a mobile device. That means:
- Short paragraphs
- Big buttons
- Clean formatting
Test your emails on your phone before you send them.
✅ DO: Include One Strong Call to Action
Each email should have one clear CTA.
That could be:
- Donate now
- Sign up for an event
- Share this story
- Forward to a friend
And yes—sometimes that CTA can just be:
👉 Subscribe to our insights newsletter (like this one!).
❌ DON’T: Skip Segmentation
Even small nonprofits can benefit from basic segmentation. Separate your list by:
- Volunteers
- Past donors
- New subscribers
- Event attendees
Tailor your message when possible. A segmented, relevant email will always outperform a generic one.
🧠 Pro Tip: Build a Reusable Newsletter Template
Creating a simple template helps you save time and build brand recognition. Include:
- A consistent header
- A short intro message
- One featured story or update
- A closing CTA
And remember: nonprofit email marketing should feel like a conversation, not a broadcast.
Ready to Level Up Your Nonprofit Email Strategy?
Email can still be your most powerful tool—if you treat it like a relationship, not a transaction.
Start building consistency, clarity, and connection today.
👇
Subscribe to our insights newsletter for smart strategies that help small nonprofits make a big impact.